Covid Nights
With bars quiet, routines broken, and takeout becoming the main event, pizza became the project. Buffalo chicken pizza was the category. Hoboken was the battlefield.
Born in Hoboken • Fueled by Covid boredom • Rated one slice at a time
The hunt for Hoboken’s best buffalo chicken pizza.
During Covid, when the world slowed down and every night started to feel the same, we created a mission: try every buffalo chicken pizza in Hoboken and crown the champ. What began as a quarantine food experiment turned into a full-blown slice-by-slice quest.
🍕
The Scorecard
- 🔥 Sauce Heat1–10
- 🐔 Chicken Load1–10
- 🧀 Cheese Pull1–10
- 🥇 Overall SliceFinal Rank
Our Origin Story
Every pizzeria. Every buffalo slice. No shortcuts.
The Rules
We judged every pie on the fundamentals: crispy crust, buffalo sauce balance, chicken coverage, ranch or blue cheese compatibility, and the all-important first-bite reaction.
The Quest Continues
What started as a neighborhood challenge became a record of the city’s best slices — and a reason to keep arguing about pizza with friends.
Think your favorite spot was robbed?
Send us the slice. We’ll bring the napkins, the hot takes, and the official scorecard.
See the Tape